Does Science Prove Alton Brown Right: Should You Stop Storing Tomatoes in the Fridge Forever?

Storing tomatoes: it’s a controversial issue. Should you always store tomatoes at room temperature, or is it safe to put them in the fridge? Some people are very vehement on this question. They’ll tell you that tomato flavour is destroyed if you store tomatoes in the fridge. They’ll tell you all about the mealy texture tomatoes get after cold storage. They may even say slightly offensive things about people who choose to keep their tomatoes in the fridge.

Growing Tomatoes in Your Garden

Tomatoes are probably the most popular of all garden vegetables. My mother always picked up a flat of hybrid tomato plants at the local garden centre. These days, I tend to shop online for heirloom tomato seeds. This way I can grow tomatoes in a whole rainbow of colours: yellow, orange, green, purple, red, and even green. If you have even the smallest patch of soil, you are probably growing at tomatoes in your vegetable garden too. And right about now, those tomatoes are ripening. Especially if you’re growing determinate tomato plants that set all of their fruit at once, lots of tomatoes are ripening!

Does Science Prove Alton Brown Right: Should You Stop Storing Tomatoes in the Fridge Forever?
Does science prove chef Alton Brown? Is it OK to store tomatoes in the fridge?

 

What’s the Deal with Storing Tomatoes?

Do you find yourself scrambling to use up all your garden-fresh tomatoes before they spoil? If you’re like most people, you’re up to your eyeballs in tomato sauce, stewed tomatoes, and BLT sandwiches right now. And you probably still have more ripe or almost-ripe tomato fruit that you don’t know what to do with. I bet you’ve been told you should never put those tomatoes in the fridge. I bet you’re also really tempted to do it!

So here’s the question: is it ever OK to refrigerate tomatoes? We already know  that a lot of gardeners and cooks are really serious about never storing tomatoes in the fridge. But does science bear out all the warnings about destroying the flavour of tomatoes if we keep them in the fridge?

This week, I took some time to dig around a bit on the internet instead of in the garden. Let me share what I learned about storing tomatoes the best way to preserve their flavour.

 

Ripe cherry tomatoes (Photo: Meditations/Pixabay/CC0)

Traditional Advice for Storing Tomatoes

I love chef Alton Brown because he talks about the science of foods. He doesn’t just teach a traditional cooking method or offer a recipe and expect people like you and me to blindly follow it, simply because he’s a chef and that’s how he does it. In fact, sometimes he makes a point of talking about the traditional advice and then he recommends that you do exactly the opposite!

Alton talks about how different ingredients contribute to a recipe and he brings in experts who can explain the scientific phenomena in everyday language. So when Alton makes a recommendation about a particular food, I tend to sit up and take notice. And when it comes to those lovely red beauties from our gardens, Alton agrees with the conventional wisdom about storing tomatoes in the fridge.

 

 

This is what Alton Brown says about tomato storage:

Do me a favor: Never put tomatoes in the refrigerator.

If they drop below 50 degrees F, a flavor compound called (Z)‑3‑hexenal is just going to flip itself off like a chemical switch … permanently.

The Zed‑3-what? And what does it mean if it switch itself off? What does that do to your tomatoes?

In order to answer that question, we first have to look at some of the components that give us that distinctive tomato flavour. As we do this, you’ll see where this hexenal stuff fits into the bigger picture. Follow me for a quick tour of tomato taste!

 

Tomato flavour is influenced by sugar content, acidity, volatile compounds, and even texture (Photo: Colliefreund/Pixabay/CC0)

 

What Makes a Tomato Taste Good?

The flavour of a tomato is a complex question. In large part, tomato flavour is a matter of the balance between the sugar content and the acidity of the fruit. A group of volatile compounds also affect the taste of your tomato. These volatile compounds help determine the smell, taste, and even the colour of the fruit.

“Volatile” means these chemicals evaporate easily at room temperature. When we brush up against the leaves of many plants, pull a ripe tomato off the vine, or slice into a tomato, the plant releases these chemicals. Another name for the essential oils used for aromatherapy and holistic medicine is “volatile oils.” They are a kind of volatile aromatic compound that we extract from plants. You could think of them as a bottled version of the many different compounds that occur naturally in the plant.

Volatile compounds in food plants help to ensure a plant’s survival by attracting pollinators or repelling insects that would cause damage. They also serve to attract our attention and signal us that a plant is good for food. Science is just beginning to understand the more than 400 volatile compounds in tomatoes. But we are already able to see that they play a key role in how we perceive the taste of a tomato. The volatile compounds help determine whether or not we’ll be satisfied with that flavour.

 

Volatile compounds are associated with scent, taste, and even colour in tomatoes (Graphic made in Canva using a public domain photo by Pixabay user Meditations)

How Volatile Compounds Impact Tomato Taste

Volatile compounds are not themselves sweet or acidic, although some of them can change how we perceive the taste of a tomato. Everyone has personal preferences when it comes to tomato flavour, but most people tend to like tomatoes that taste sweet.

This can mean that the tomato has a high sugar content, as measured in Brix. Some examples of tomatoes with a high sugar content would be a ‘Candyland Red’ currant tomato or ‘Fantastico,’ both hybrid tomatoes measured at 12 °Bx. A Brandywine heirloom tomato might be even sweeter, with a whopping 14 °Bx. All of these tomatoes are as sweet as any fruit – and science can measure that sweetness objectively.

But a tomato may also have a lower actual sugar content and it will still taste sweet because it is also low in acid. Certain volatile compounds like geranial can also make a tomato seem sweeter, regardless of the balance of sugar and acid in its fruit.

 

The Chemistry of Tomatoes
(Z)-3-hexenal and Geranial are Volatile Compounds that Contribute to the Tomato’s Flavour

Why Storing Tomatoes in Your Fridge isn’t the Best Idea

So what does all this have to do with where you store your tomatoes? Was Alton right? And what is this hexenal stuff, anyway?

Let’s start with the volatile compound itself. Other names for (Z)‑3‑hexenal include cis‑3‑Hexenal and 3‑hexenal. This compound belongs to a group of chemicals known as aldehydes, which you may have encountered if you know a little something about perfumery. Chanel No. 5 is one famous perfume that relies on aldehydes to lift its floral foundation.

What is 3-Hexenal?

3‑Hexenal is an aldehyde with a sharp green scent, like the smell of freshly cut grass. Hexenal is found in many food plants, including apples, cucumbers, berries, and even black tea. The leaves and fruit of the tomato plant both contain hexenal. It also happens to be one of the most abundant volatile compounds in tomatoes, which might just be why our friend, chef Alton Brown makes specific mention of it in his tomato storage advice.

The leaf aldehyde, as it is sometimes called when discussing it as an aroma compound, is actually just one of over 400 volatile components that scientists have identified in tomatoes. These compounds begin to develop when the fruit starts to ripen and we know that they contribute to the taste, smell, and texture of a ripe tomato – or what is sometimes just called the “flavour.” We don’t fully understand the role of all these 400 odd chemical components of the fruit. But it does seem that in cases where they are missing or only present in small amounts, the tomato’s flavour and even its appearance can suffer.

 

Heirloom tomatoes are preferred by many people because of their superior flavour (Photo: magdus/Pixabay/CC0)

 

3-Hexenal and Cold Temperatures

So the 3-hexenal is the reason we’re concerned about storing tomatoes in the fridge. You see, the volatile compounds in a tomato are reduced when that tomato is subjected to the cold. Even though its sugar and acid content remain constant this will change the flavour. So when we bite into that tomato, it doesn’t satisfy us the way it normally would. In fact, some scientists have found that if a tomato is held at temperatures below 12°C, the volatile compounds actually  switch right off. This is what Alton is talking about.

If a tomato is not fully ripe, storing it in the cold can prevent it from ripening and developing its flavour. And if you keep any tomato in the cold for too long, it can lead to a chilling injury – the same sort of damage that occurs to plants in your vegetable garden when there’s a hard frost. So we want to be sure to let unripe tomatoes sit out at room temperature in order for them to ripen properly. And once ripe, we want to be careful about how we store them. It’s best to eat ripe tomatoes within a couple of days, or to process them for later use. You can keep your tomatoes fresher for a bit longer if you flip them over and store them with the stem scar down.

 

How to store tomatoes in the fridge and how to recondition them afterwards (Photo: Meditations/Pixabay/CC0)

 

Is Storing Tomatoes in the Fridge Ever OK?

If at all possible, store tomatoes in a cool spot out of direct sunlight. They fare best at temperatures between about 12°C to 20°C – that’s 55°F to 70°F, for those who still prefer the Fahrenheit scale. If your kitchen is much hotter than 20°C, you may want to store your tomatoes in a cool pantry or a wine fridge designed to keep the temperature cool but not cold.

If there really isn’t anywhere in your home that is cool enough, you may just find that you have to store ripe tomatoes in the fridge. Leaving them out in a very warm kitchen only hastens the processes that lead to rotting. So if you aren’t able to eat or process them hast enough, you can extend their shelf life by a few days by putting them in the warmest part of your fridge – usually near the front of the top shelf.

Reconditioning Refrigerated Tomatoes

Scientists have discovered that tomatoes stored in the fridge can be reconditioned. Remove them from the fridge 24 hours before eating and leave them on the kitchen counter to warm up. This restores some, but not all, of the volatile compounds lost from storing tomatoes in the cold. This reconditioning process works on fully ripe tomatoes that have been kept at 4°C for up to 6 days.

So if you can avoid  storing tomatoes in the fridge, follow Alton’s advice and keep your tomatoes at room temperature. Storing tomatoes in the fridge before they are fully ripe may prevent them from ripening. And even ripe tomatoes can suffer from chilling damage. This will turn their texture mealy and rob them of their full flavour.

But what if you’ve just brought in a huge harvest of ripe, red tomatoes from your heirloom vegetable garden and you can’t possibly process them all fast enough? It’s OK to put the fruit in your fridge to keep it from rotting. This will give you a few extra days to make your tomato sauce or slice your tomatoes for drying in your dehydrator.

 

Storing tomatoes: fridge or countertop? How to store tomatoes from the garden – and where to do it | 24 Carrot Diet | food storage | heirloom tomatoes | chef Alton Brown | tomato flavour | volatile compounds
How to Properly Store Tomatoes – and Where to Do It
PLEASE PIN THIS ARTICLE – remember sharing is caring!
Graphic made in Canva using a public domain photo by Pixabay user 2PDPics

 

Did you enjoy this article? Check out some related content below!

HOW TO STORE LEAFY GREEN VEGETABLES SO THEY’LL STAY FRESH

How to store lettuce and other greens to extend their shelf life (Graphic made in Canva; copyrighted photo by Margaret Osborne, used with permission)
SEE IT NOW | PIN IT FOR LATER

 

ELIMINATE FOOD WASTE: HOW TO REPURPOSE KITCHEN SCRAPS

You don’t have to turn freegan to reduce food waste and get free food! (Graphic made in Canva using a public domain photo by Pixabay user 2PDPics)
SEE IT NOW | PIN IT FOR LATER

 

WHAT TO DO WITH UNRIPE TOMATOES: GREEN TOMATO PIE

Green tomato pie is a sweet substitute for apple pie – and it’s a great way to use unripe tomatoes from your vegetable garden! (Graphic made in Canva using a public domain photo by Pixabay user PublicDomainImages)
SEE IT NOW | PIN IT FOR LATER

 

Original content © 2017 Kyla Matton Osborne, aka #RubyWriter

This article was published on my food blog, 24 Carrot Diet. If you are reading this content anywhere else, it has probably been stolen. Please report it to me so I can address any copyright infringements. Thank you!

14 thoughts on “Does Science Prove Alton Brown Right: Should You Stop Storing Tomatoes in the Fridge Forever?”

    1. We buy a lot more canned tomatoes for cooking too, Jill. I buy a lot of grape tomatoes off-season instead of trying to get the slicing tomatoes at the grocery store. Unless I'm really craving a tomato sandwich or something, I generally don't buy larger tomatoes except in season. We grew our own this summer after several years of not gardening. The yield wasn't great, so we've been supplementing with tomatoes from the farmers market.
  1. I don't like tomatoes so I don't buy them. I don't really like the flavor. But, after reading this my mother always stored the tomatoes in the fridge so perhaps the storing is the problem. I might give tomatoes another chance.
    1. I never liked tomatoes when I was growing up so I can totally relate to why you avoid them, Yulissa. My mother stored hers in the fridge and I disliked the mealy texture many of them took on. I started to enjoy tomatoes only after I'd tried a few different types that were available then at the grocery store. Some have much better flavour, for example the sweet grape tomatoes most stores have now. Do you like things that have tomato in them? Like tomato juice or V8, or tomato-based spaghetti sauces? If so, it may be that you just need to find some good fresh tomatoes to taste. Try shopping at a farmers market. Look for the heirloom tomatoes, which often come in vastly different shapes and sizes, and may also be yellow, orange, green, or even purple/black instead of red. Heirloom tomatoes tend to have better flavour than commercially grown hybrids. And they were probably picked fresh before coming to market, or were ripened naturally. Grocery store tomatoes have often been picked green and then ripened chemically and stored in the cold. So their flavour is diminished even before you bring them home.
  2. It's funny but this is the second time in a week I've heard about storing tomatoes stem down. I had never heard that tip before. We've always stored our tomatoes in the fridge. This may explain why sometimes the flavor just isn't the same. We think it's a bad season, but it's because we're storing them incorrectly. Thanks for this good information! (And, yes, we are being inundated with tomatoes right now...LOL)
    1. If they are fresh from the garden, try to keep tomatoes on the counter. If you're buying them off-season from the grocery store, it actually might not matter so much. Apparently, the commercially grown tomatoes have a lower level of volatile compounds to begin with. And they are often chilled before they reach the grocery store. So it's mostly the texture that would be affected, if anything.
      1. Kyla, Thanks for the tip! I suspect that commercially grown tomatoes are picked so early that the quality isn't the same anyway. At least, they never taste the same as tomatoes you grow. That stands true for most produce, though.
  3. Hi! I came from Carol's over here. My Granny and Grandma both told us NEVER store tomatoes in the fridge. So, we never do! Except for spaghetti sauce, leftovers of course! Good to know they were scientifically correct!
    1. Thanks for popping by! It is cool when we discover that our grannies were doing it right. Science may take a little while to come along and explain it, but often the old ways are the best.
  4. Reblogged this on Retired? No one told me! and commented: I think this is a really interesting post about tomatoes and how to store them...It has also addressed the problem if you live in sunnier climes like Moi..which is great as you often get one-sided do and don'ts which most of the time doesn't include climates like mine... A great post which I really like :)
  5. Since it is just me I usually use my store or farmer's market tomatoes quickly, most of the time eating them like an apple. I just leave them on the counter and it reminds me to eat them. But this information is good to know. I never would have guessed the fridge might ruin the taste of my tomato fruits!
    1. If you are keeping them on the counter, you can keep tomatoes fresher for a longer time by flipping it over so the scar from the stem is facing down.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge